Getting Even: Forgiveness and Its LimitsOxford University Press, 2003 M03 27 - 152 páginas We have all been victims of wrongdoing. Forgiving that wrongdoing is one of the staples of current pop psychology dogma; it is seen as a universal prescription for moral and mental health in the self-help and recovery section of bookstores. At the same time, personal vindictiveness as a rule is seen as irrational and immoral. In many ways, our thinking on these issues is deeply inconsistent; we value forgiveness yet at the same time now use victim-impact statements to argue for harsher penalties for criminals. Do we have a right to hate others for what they have done to us? The distinguished philosopher and law professor Jeffrie Murphy is a skeptic when it comes to our views on both emotions. In this short and accessible book, he proposes that vindictive emotions (anger, resentment, and the desire for revenge) actually deserve a more legitimate place in our emotional, social, and legal lives than we currently recognize, while forgiveness deserves to be more selectively granted. Murphy grounds his views on careful analysis of the nature of forgiveness, a subtle understanding of the psychology of anger and resentment, and a fine appreciation of the ethical issues of self-respect and self-defense. He also uses accessible examples from law, literature, and religion to make his points. Providing a nuanced approach to a proper understanding of the place of our strongest emotions in moral, political, and personal life, and using lucid, easily understood prose, this volume is a classic example of philosophical thinking applied to a thorny, everyday problem. |
Contenido
Responding to Evil | 3 |
1 What Is Forgiveness? | 9 |
2 Two Cheers for Vindictiveness | 17 |
3 Vindictiveness and the Law | 27 |
4 Forgiveness as a Virtue | 33 |
5 Repentance Punishment and Mercy | 39 |
6 SelfForgiveness | 57 |
7 Forgiveness in Psychotheraphy | 73 |
8 Forgiveness and Christianity | 87 |
9 Christianity and Criminal Punishment | 95 |
Concluding Remarks | 115 |
Further Reading | 119 |
125 | |
Otras ediciones - Ver todas
Términos y frases comunes
argued believe Bishop Butler called capital punishment chapter Christian claim client concept context counseling course crime criminal law criminal punishment death penalty deep character defiance degree deserves deterrence discussion emotions Enright essay evil example explore Fay Weldon fear feel giveness guilt harm hasty human immorality inflicted injury intentionally left blank irrational ishment issue J. L. Austin Jean Hampton Jesus justice Kant Kant’s kind least legal punishment legitimate luck Marilyn Adams mens rea ment mercy merely Michael Kohlhaas moral hatred moral rebirth murder ness one’s passage paternalistic theory perhaps person Peter Strawson philosophical counseling philosophical counselor prison psychotherapy question rape rational reason reconciliation relevant religious repentance respect responsibility retribution revenge role secular seek self-forgiveness self-hatred self-loathing self-respect sense sentencing sermon simply skepticism social sometimes soul story suffering surely thing tion understand vengeance victim impact statements vindictive passions virtue of forgiveness writings wrong wrongdoer wrongdoing